What Happens When Merchants Lose A Chargeback Dispute?

Losing a chargeback dispute for a merchant is devastating. You’re not just dealing with the potential for higher credit card processing fees and chargeback fees; you’re also out of all the time you spent dealing with the dispute. This article breaks down what happens when you lose a chargeback as a merchant and provides some methods to help avoid chargebacks in the future.

Key Takeaways

    • When you lose a chargeback, you are on the hook for all shipping fees, cost of goods, chargeback fees, and refund fees.

    • Your chargeback ratio increases which mean you could pay higher fees

    • If your chargeback ratio is over 1%, you will run into serious problems and may end up on the Mastercard MATCH list

    • By partnering with CB-ALERT, you can win more disputes and analyze your data to stamp out fraud immediately.

Consequences of Losing a Chargeback:

    • Loss of Revenue: One of the most significant consequences of losing a chargeback dispute is the immediate loss of revenue. The merchant must refund the disputed amount when a chargeback is ruled in the cardholder’s favor. This means that not only do they lose the revenue from the original sale, but they also bear the financial burden of the chargeback amount.

    • Product or Service Loss: In addition to losing revenue, merchants may also lose the product or service they provided to the customer. In cases where the product has already been shipped or the service has been rendered, merchants cannot recover these goods. This double loss of revenue and inventory can substantially impact a merchant’s bottom line.

    • Financial Penalties and Fees: Chargebacks often incur additional financial penalties and fees. Throughout the chargeback process, merchants may incur investigation fees charged by the acquiring bank or payment processor for reviewing and handling the dispute. If the dispute proceeds to arbitration, the associated fees can be even higher, ranging from hundreds to thousands of dollars. These fees further erode the merchant’s profits and add to the financial burden of the chargeback.

    • Impact on Cash Flow: Chargebacks can disrupt a merchant’s cash flow. When a chargeback occurs, the acquiring bank debits the funds from the merchant’s account to reimburse the cardholder. This sudden withdrawal of funds can strain a merchant’s cash flow, making it challenging to cover operational expenses, purchase inventory, or fulfill other financial obligations.

    • Damage to Reputation: Repeated chargebacks can damage a merchant’s reputation and credibility. Excessive chargebacks raise concerns about the quality of products or services, customer satisfaction, and the overall trustworthiness of the merchant. Negative reviews and complaints about chargebacks can spread quickly, making attracting new customers and retaining existing ones challenging. Moreover, a high chargeback ratio can result in penalties or even the termination of merchant accounts by payment processors or acquiring banks.

    • Increased Scrutiny and Monitoring: Merchants with a history of chargebacks may face increased scrutiny from payment processors, acquiring banks, and card associations. They may be subject to additional monitoring and compliance requirements, which can be time-consuming and costly. This heightened scrutiny can limit the merchant’s ability to access certain payment processing services or negotiate favorable terms.

    • Difficulty Obtaining Merchant Accounts: Losing chargeback disputes can make it more challenging for merchants to obtain new merchant accounts or maintain existing ones. Acquiring banks and payment processors consider chargeback ratios and the merchant’s track record when assessing the risk associated with providing services. A high chargeback ratio can make it challenging to secure favorable terms or even lead to the denial of merchant account applications.

Choose CB-ALERT And Lower Your Chargeback Ratio

    • Industry Expertise: CB-Alert has over two decades of experience in the merchant services industry. This deep understanding of the intricacies of chargebacks allows CB-Alert to develop highly effective strategies and tools to reduce chargeback ratios.

    • Customizable and Scalable: We understand that every business is unique and has different needs. The highly customizable platform allows merchants to tailor the solution to their specific requirements. CB-Alert can quickly scale and adapt as your business grows to accommodate your evolving needs.

    • Data-Driven Decision Making: CB-Alert takes the guesswork out of chargeback management by providing merchants with real-time data and analytics access. This empowers merchants to make informed decisions based on reliable insights, enabling them to prevent chargebacks and reduce their ratio proactively.

    • Automation and Efficiency: CB-Alert’s automated processes streamline chargeback management, reducing the manual effort required and minimizing the potential for errors. By automating repetitive tasks, merchants can save time and focus on more critical aspects of their business.

    • Proactive Fraud Prevention: CB-Alert goes beyond simply managing chargebacks. The platform incorporates advanced fraud prevention measures to identify and prevent fraudulent transactions before they result in chargebacks. CB-Alert helps merchants maintain a low chargeback ratio by proactively stopping fraud at its source.


The consequences of losing a chargeback can be detrimental to a merchant’s financial stability, reputation, and overall business operations. 

Merchants must implement strategies to minimize chargebacks, such as improving customer service, streamlining order fulfillment processes, and implementing fraud prevention measures. 

By understanding the chargeback process and taking proactive steps, merchants can mitigate the impact of chargebacks and protect their businesses from unnecessary losses.

Now that you understand what happens when merchants lose a chargeback get in touch with us so we can develop a chargeback management strategy to take your business to the next level

Scroll to Top